The ‘Soul Mate’ List: Good or Bad Idea?

Santa isn’t the only one with a list around this time of year. Holidays inspire reflection, and part of that reflection is often the reevaluation of our love lives. Single ladies and fellows may have a list this time of year; I’d like to encourage them to check it twice.
Creating That Soul Mate
At some point, most of us create a list – sometimes on paper, sometimes just in our heads. We brainstorm important qualities we value in a mate. Some lists are very detailed and arranged in order of priority, emphasizing must-haves and deal-breakers. They range from physical attributes to personal habits to religious beliefs. My list emphasized the concept that my dream man must be in the ballpark of my height and though he didn’t have to be a yogi, he had to be open to trying a class – he couldn’t be one of those guys who says yoga is for girls (those types of men seriously need to open up their heart charkas).
Don’t You Want Me, Baby?
My friend Tammie had an extensive list. Cuban, Mexican and Jewish, Tammie would prefer her future husband to both share her faith and speak Spanish. Also — she’d be thrilled if he wore glasses and fuzzy sweaters and had an appreciation for new wave 80’s pop. Over the years, we tried to find Tammie’s husband, resulting in many awkward dates with guys with names like Alejandro Greenberg and Guillermo Schwartz. Now in her thirties, she’s dating a Frenchman — not Jewish — but he adores her and she pointed out that after all, French and Spanish are both romance languages.
I’m not saying the list is a bad thing – If you know what you want in a companion, you won’t waste anybody’s time or break anyone’s heart looking for it. If a woman knows she doesn’t want children and she’s on a date with a guy whose biological alarm clock went off yesterday, it’s probably best for both parties to part ways – I’m suggesting that a list should be a rough draft. One shouldn’t stick so closely to it that they ignore a fantastic person right in front of them or miss an opportunity for love.
Making a List in Invisible Ink
Our lists will shift as we grow. My husband spent a good chunk of his twenties on tour with Phish. If someone pointed out a Phish fan when I was twenty-three, I would have turned up my nose. Ew, next. But now that I’m a semi-adult, I can see the bigger picture. Sadly, I haven’t developed an affinity for half hour live jams, buI love him as a complete person. I appreciate his generous nature, his creativity, his dry sense of humor, and the way he remembers to buy toilet paper and paper towels. He is my favorite yoga buddy.
I propose that single folks keep their lists, but write them in pencil. Or on a chalkboard. So as you grow and change, you can erase or add. Stay true to the must-haves and deal-breakers, but open up to other qualities.
As we become fuller people and appreciate our blessings in life, we may gain new perspective on and open up to different visions of happiness and love.
[Photo by ||!prliignore0||]
The copyright of the article The ‘Soul Mate’ List: Good or Bad Idea? in Partnership is owned by Carrieanddanielle.com. Permission to republish The ‘Soul Mate’ List: Good or Bad Idea? in print or online must be granted by the author in writing.
Read more at Carrie and Danielle: Partnership


January 2nd, 2009 at 8:13 am
Beautiful. Thank you, Carolyn!
January 2nd, 2009 at 11:14 am
burn the list. light a match, right now. lists get in the way of your heart and smarts.
January 2nd, 2009 at 2:31 pm
yes!! It's important to know your deal-breakers, otherwise you could waste a lot of time being unhappy without knowing why. But most lists are garbage. I always thought my partner would be 2 inches taller and 2 years older than me, so when the right man came along I didn't recognize him. 2 inches shorter, 16 years older, bald and unemployed – who knew? I just married him after almost 10 ridiculously fun, passionate, and adventurous years together. Still having the time of my life.
January 4th, 2009 at 5:34 am
I love this. It is so true. My husband would have never made the “list” I made in my single 20's. And Thank God for that! I threw the list out the window when I looked around and found list was keeping me single…and there he was.
January 4th, 2009 at 1:01 pm
I don't believe in soul mates and lists prevent one from being present to the unusual, the mysterious and the suprises in life. Well said Carolyn
January 5th, 2009 at 10:51 am
Strangely – I wrote a list in 2001 and when I dug it out a little while ago, my husband was all of it, and more. I found it a really useful exercise, and the main points on it haven't changed. It was actually a good way to reflect on myself as well. I'm all for the list!
February 27th, 2009 at 1:15 pm
I think accepting the flaws of your partner would get in the way of your list. As long as you don't see negative with your partner everything would be wonderful. Our partner is our choice, after all there can be no perfect partner. We get to love a person for who he is.